“I Believe I Can Fly” by R. Kelly

R. Kelly seemed to have garnered something of a divisive reputation within the R&B field, partly due to his uneven output (he has produced his share of catchy but stupid booty-jams like “You Remind Me of Something”, and most of his albums feature significant amounts of filler) and partly because of certain actions in his personal life that I have neither the qualifications nor the inclination to discuss here. And while I won’t deny either of the abovementioned points, the fact still remains that R. Kelly is a supremely talented R&B songwriter and producer, one of the best of his generation. As for this song, which most would agree catches him at his absolute peak, it has been a perennial favorite ever since it was first released as the soundtrack theme for a ridiculous summer blockbuster, one of the few songs of its era to achieve the level of ubiquity and enduring affection that the Great American Songbook standards were known for. While this has actually been a bit of a mixed blessing for the song, as so many of us can whistle its melody by now that we sometimes forget how ravishing it is on first listen, it is still a rare badge of honor for a song that came out as late as the Nineties, and we should respect this song for it…after all, anyone can win an award or top the charts; becoming a beloved classic is a much more difficult achievement.

Verdict: Good.

“Somebody” by Natalie La Rose and Jeremih

This song, with its combination of pretty female vocals and an imitation-DJ Mustard beat, is far from unlistenable, and certainly the best charting hit Jeremih had appeared on up to that point. But frankly, we already had a Pop song sampled from Whitney Houston’s “Dance With Somebody”, that came out a year earlier and deserved to be a hit far more than this one: it was called “Somebody Loves You” by Indie Pop singer Betty Who. So this song basically lives in the shadow of two vastly better songs, and frankly that’s more than its moderately pleasant frame can really support.

Verdict: Not exactly bad, just kind of redundant.

“The Gambler” by Kenny Rogers

It actually pains me to have to say anything nice about a song made famous by the most disgustingly maudlin country singer in what was a very maudlin era for country. After all, this is the man who made “Ruby, Don’t Take Your Love To Town” a hit, and his entire career has a well-deserved reputation for melodramatic schlock. But Rogers neither wrote nor originated this song, so his association with it is based more on luck than anything else, and in the end, I really can’t deny this song’s status as a well-deserved country classic. The unforgettable chorus is iconic for a reason, and the lyrics in general are some of the best ever in a Country song. In fact, I’d guess that part of the reason that Kenny Rogers is marginally less hated than he deserves to be is that there’s a fair number of people who’ve never heard any of his songs except this one.

Verdict: Good

“Drops in Jupiter” by Train

Even though I called this band the worst Soft Rock act of the modern era (and I stand by that statement), even a terrible band can still have one good song. Granted, their early stuff in general wasn’t as horrible as “Hey Soul Sister” and “Drive By”, but it wasn’t exactly auspicious either. Still, this one Grammy-winning modern classic pretty much represents their all-time peak. Train are usually compared to Nineties Adult Alternative pioneers the Counting Crows, sometimes to the point of borderline plagiarism, but this monolithic, sweeping ballad sounds more reminiscent of Elton John (specifically, his Madman Across the Water album). The lyrics do feature one example of the bizarre word choices that would become their hallmark (an out-of-nowhere line comparing love to ‘deep fried chicken’), but apart from that, they rein in their lyrical problems for the most part. Even after the huge undeserved success they’ve achieved in the last few years, this still ranks as Train’s biggest hit, and it’s certainly the only song of theirs to deserve that status. I guess it stands as proof that even this idiot pack are capable of pulling it all together for one great moment.

Verdict: Good

“Revolution 9” by the Beatles

This song has a rather notorious reputation, and is generally regarded as the Beatles’ one major misstep. And I will admit that it is a strange and rather terrifying collage of sound, insane enough to make all the greatest excesses of the forthcoming Progressive Rock era look paltry by comparison. But it deserves a certain measure of respect for its sheer ambition and creativity. Yes, it requires you to completely redefine your definition of ‘music’ in order to enjoy it, but one could argue that’s a good thing…after all, challenging preconceived notions of logical limits has always been how the great musical innovators have advanced the form. And since plenty of works that make far more exacting demands (such as Lou Reed’s Metal Machine Music) are acknowledged as having been vindicated by history, maybe its time we re-evaluated our position on this first great example of noise being turned into music. I’d argue that this is actually one of the Beatles’ most impressive and forward-looking moments, and it proves that Yoko Ono’s crazy avant-garde ideas about music did at least have some degree of merit in the beginning.

Verdict: Good. No, I’m not kidding.

“Ice Ice Baby” by Vanilla Ice

On the surface, this song would appear to not be as bad as its reputation suggests. The hook may be stolen from “Under Pressure”, but at least that guarantees a good hook (you know what they say, steal from the best), and the lyrics, while certainly not good by any standard, are nowhere near as bad as those of most of the other widely reviled Rap acts out there (Soulja Boy, Insane Clown Posse, the Black Eyed Peas, etc.). But the problem with Vanilla Ice was never really his lyrics, as is the case with most bad rappers. The thing that made him so hated was his smug, obnoxious performing style…not just his inauthentic persona (although that didn’t help), but his total lack of even a shred of performing charisma and his repellent attitude that just made you hate him from the moment you heard his voice. Ice’s noxious performance poisons every aspect of this song, to the point where even the stolen hook comes off as annoying, and based on that, the song pretty much deserves the reception it’s invariably gotten.

Verdict: Bad

“Ruby, Don’t Take Your Love to Town” by Kenny Rogers

This is one of the ugliest, most mean-spirited songs I’ve ever heard, pointlessly depressing and unpleasant and with a particularly noxious streak of misogyny to boot. Granted, there were plenty of maudlin Country ballads circulating in the late Sixties, but songs like “Little Green Apples” and “Honey” were generally maudlin in a saccharinely sentimental way, not in an ugly and cruel way like this abomination. I can’t believe the great Country songwriter Mel Tillis wrote this thing, or that it became such a Country standard that talented singers like Waylon Jennings and Roger Miller ended up recording it. But Kenny Rogers is the one who made it a hit, and it set the tone for the entire remainder of his career…it’s hard to see songs like “Coward of the County” as anything but an attempt to make another “Ruby”.

Verdict: This is one of the worst songs I have ever heard in my life, and given what I’ve covered elsewhere on this site, you should know I do not make that statement lightly.

“Honey, I’m Good” by Andy Grammer

This song isn’t exactly an immortal classic, but it was a highly pleasant and quite refreshing alternative to the sleazy Country “love” songs prevalent in the genre at the time…a song about turning down the beautiful piece of ass because you already have someone at home and intend to remain faithful to them. Granted, the ode to marital fidelity in the face of temptation has been done better many times in Country music (so many, in fact, that the Classic Country supergroup the Old Dogs even parodied it with “Cut the Mustard”), but it’s still nice to see that tried-and-true (no pun intended) song model making a comeback, especially given what had supplanted it lately.

Verdict: Good.

“Full Moon and Empty Arms” by Bob Dylan

Bob Dylan has had rather mixed luck with cover albums—he’s put out a couple of decent ones, like Good as I Been To You and World Gone Wrong, but the three albums widely acknowledged as his worst…Self-Portrait, Dylan, and Christmas In the Heart…all consisted primarily of covers. And while Dylan’s voice has actually improved in his old age…now he just sounds like an extremely grizzled old Blues singer…this song was based on a Rachmaninoff concerto, and I was skeptical of Dylan’s ability to do it vocal justice. But I was pleasantly surprised than Dylan, even in his seventies, can still pull off the soft croon he displayed on such albums as Nashville Skyline, and his voice sounds about as good here as it has in decades. This isn’t remotely on a level with the tracks on Dylan’s last album, Tempest, but it is a perfectly pleasant rendition of a classic song, and given as strange a project as Bob Dylan covering Frank Sinatra, that’s about the best we could have hoped for.

Verdict: Good, surprisingly enough.

“Everything I Do (I Do It For You)” by Bryan Adams

This song isn’t bad in the actively unpleasant way…it’s just so incredibly lackluster. Everything about it, from the dull, lifeless melody to the utterly uninspired lyrics to Bryan Adams’ energy-free performance that fails to turn his raspy voice into an asset like it was on most of his previous work, just screams that this song had no effort put into it at all. As a Rock power ballad, it’s surpassed by the strikingly similar but vastly more intense and musically interesting “November Rain” from around the same time, and as an Oscar Bait song, it was surpassed by its own parody, the surprisingly attractive “Marian” from Mel Brook’s Robin Hood: Men In Tights. That last fact should be enough to completely seal the deal on this song’s failure.

Verdict: Bad