“Your Body is a Wonderland” by John Mayer

John Mayer gets very little respect, and what little he does get is mostly accorded to his later, more sophisticated Rock albums, with his first two efforts in particular bearing the brunt of contemporary rock snobs’ scorn. And while I’ve caved to pressure in the past and said some negative things about those albums on my other site, I’ve never entirely understood this hatred. John Mayer is essentially a modern-day Easy Listening act, true, but Easy Listening is by no means automatically bad, and while acoustic folk-rock has acquired a not entirely undeserved reputation for musical laziness, Mayer isn’t guilty of that himself…say what you will, but he really knows how to play that guitar. Unlike most ultra-softcore sex jams (e.g. “Afternoon Delight”), “Your Body Is a Wonderland” works because it genuinely sounds tender and gentle rather than coy. This is a totally convincing soundtrack to a very gentle, slightly tentative lovemaking session between two inexperienced kids who are deeply in love with each other, and since that is a perfectly valid subject to write a song about and is clearly exactly what Mayer was going for, I have to conclude this song is a success.

Verdict: Good.

“We Are the World” by USA for Africa

Not everyone knows it, but this famous pop-culture embarrassment was co-written by the legendary King of Pop himself, Michael Jackson, who would use it as a dry run for several much better songs in the same vein, especially the beautiful “Man In the Mirror”. As for the song itself, it certainly had enviable star power, with a heretofore unimaginable stable of living legends in one place, all of whom sound great on the single, and the tune is memorable, which might explains why, although everyone hates and laughs at this song today, everyone remembers it too. Granted, the lyrics are empty, hypocritical grandstanding, with their self-centered worldview (as in the notorious line “We’re saving our own lives”, or even the very title), and their attempt to apply stale inspirational platitudes to real-world problems. But I think the real problem is that the entire Charity Single genre was one of the uglier, more shameful excesses of the Eighties, embodying that time’s tendency toward condescending generosity and a patronizing treatment of the Third World in general, and this is, after all, the song that has come to represent that entire genre in the public memory, even though it was probably the best thing the genre would produce in that era.

Verdict: This song was basically a terrible idea well executed, but given that we’ve seen the same idea with much worse execution many times over the years, I can’t be too hard on it.

“Behind Blue Eyes” by Limp Bizkit

Despite this cover’s reputation as a horrific decesration of the Who’s original, it’s not really as terrible as it sounds, and in fact is probably the best thing Limp Bizkit ever recorded (not that there’s much competition for that title). The fact remains that the song itself is light-years ahead of their usual material, and in spite of the hoards of Rock fans that (perhaps understandably) considered the mere idea of Limp Bizkit covering the Who to be tantamount to blasphemy, Fred Durst does appear to be taking the song seriously, and his singing here is slightly better than on most of the band’s other songs. I wouldn’t go too far to defend this…it’s still a rather dull, by-the-numbers cover, and certainly comparing it with the original is like comparing Van Gogh’s Starry Night to the scribblings of an average four-year-old. But a mediocre cover of a great song is still much better than most of Limp Bizkit’s output.

Verdict: Mediocre at best, but by Limp Bizkit’s standards, it might as well be a masterpiece.

“Ass Like That” by Eminem

Eminem has openly admitted that the era of his career that produced this single was his absolute low point. He was reportedly grappling with an addiction to prescription drugs that nearly killed him, and apparently that crisis also led him to write a string of incredibly stupid and juvenile songs. This song was apparently Eminem’s attempt to get his own back after being insulted by Triumph the Insult Comic Dog (though in a clearly tongue-in-cheek way, as the aforementioned puppet was actually featured in the video). Eminem is usually quite adept at that kind of retaliatory skewering, but all he could come up with here was writing verses that entailed Triumph (represented by Eminem doing the puppet’s trademark fake accent) being arrested for various lewd and disgusting things, built around a chorus that features what are probably the stupidest lyrics Eminem has ever written for anything (“It makes my peepee go ‘Doing, doing, doing’!”). Eminem has since apologized profusely to fans for this song and the album that contained it, but even at the time, he seemed to be aware on some level of how embarrassing this song was, as he closes the track by having Dr. Dre shout, “The fuck is wrong with you?!” I can only echo that sentiment.

Verdict: Bad

“St. Anger” by Metallica

For their first five albums (yes, I’m including the so-called “Black Album”), Metallica were one of the finest Heavy Metal bands in the world. But I’m not going to play Devil’s Advocate with this one—there’s really nothing I can say in defense of this song or the album it came from, and I’m not going to try. The first problem with this song is that it is, quite unmistakably, a Nu-Metal song in the style of bands like Korn or Limp Bizkit. Given that Metallica’s primary target audience tends to have complete contempt for that variety of metal (and to be fair, they aren’t the only ones), this alone almost guaranteed a poor reception. But there’s plenty to hate about this track even if you like that kind of music—the sloppy, random drumming, the pretentious, idiotic lyrics, the bargain-basement production—even lead singer James Hetfield is in terrible voice. This is perhaps the most legendarily awful heavy metal track in history, and certainly the most notorious one to be released by a good band.

Verdict: Bad

“I Write the Songs” by Barry Manilow

Barry Manilow had his detractors in his day, but they have gradually died out, and today most people are either unreserved fans or at least see him as a guilty pleasure. Of all his signature hits, this is the only one that it still just as widely hated as it ever was. Granted, the tune is sound enough, if admittedly not the equal of the other big Manilow hits, and Manilow performs it quite strongly. Also granted, the problem people have with the lyrics is technically the result of a misinterpretation, but since practically everybody who hears the song is guilty of that misinterpretation, the logical conclusion is that the problem is probably on the original songwriter’s end. The song is supposed to be sung from the perspective of an abstract embodiment of music itself like the Nine Muses from Greek mythology, but it’s not really reasonable to expect the song’s listeners to make that rather bizarre leap in logic. Audiences are always going to take this song at face value as an insanely grandiose boast, and it’s really not their fault so much as the songwriter’s, for coming up with such a contrived conceit for his song in the first place.

Verdict: Bad

“Wives and Lovers” by Burt Bacharach and Hal David

Burt Bacharach was one of the finest pop tunesmiths of his generation, but he always had trouble finding lyricists worthy of his talents. Hal David is generally considered his greatest collaborator, but only by default, as David’s frequently hamfisted lyrics often hampered Bacharach’s wonderful tunes. This song’s melody is terrific, and it was wildly popular in its day (no less a talent than the great Ella Fitzgerald recorded it—twice!), but its take on gender relations has aged so horribly that today, one would hardly dare to play it in public. There was no shortage of sexist popular songs in the Sixties, but this one ranks just short of Phil Spector’s “He Hit Me (It Felt Like a Kiss)” in terms of offensiveness.

Verdict: Bad

“My Heart Will Go On” by Celine Dion

No-one involved in this song seemed to have wanted to do it—James Horner didn’t want to adapt his instrumental theme into a song, Celine Dion didn’t want to record it when she first heard it, and James Cameron, who wanted a hit pop song to promote his movie, spent the entire process second-guessing himself for being ‘too commercial’. The resulting song is certainly cheesy and melodramatic, but let’s remember that it’s still based on a James Horner theme, so the melody is strong, and that Celine Dion was always a fabulous vocalist (and has certainly sung many worse songs that this, despite its reputation as her low point).

Verdict: Pretty good, actually (and certainly not nearly as bad as it’s generally made out to be).

“The Millenium Prayer” by Cliff Richards

This insipid charity single is a perfect example of the laziness and lack of effort that pervades the modern Christian community’s attempts at art. Basically, it’s Cliff Richard singing the words of the Lord’s Prayer to the tune of “Auld Lang Syne”. Not only does it not even come close to scanning, but we already had a much better musical setting of the Lord’s Prayer that’s been sung by everyone from Mahalia Jackson to Andrea Bocelli. If Richard really wanted to make a pop single version of the Lord’s Prayer, why didn’t he just use that one?

Verdict: Good tune and good words, but exceptionally bad combination of the two

“Bad Blood” by Taylor Swift and Kendrick Lamar

This extremely striking song from Taylor Swift’s 1989 album was easily the most intense of all her ‘angry’ songs up to that point, making even “Better Than Revenge” look lightweight by comparison. Granted, the lyrics are not up to Swift’s best work and can get a little cheesy, but they are ultimately overpowered by the compelling music, with its quietly intense verses and monstrously epic hook. Unfortunately, the single version dilutes a lot of the impact of the song…Kendrick Lamar, in Swift’s first serious collaboration with a rapper, offers some of his weakest work to date, much of the enraged intensity of the original album version is lost, and the whole thing feels far more conventional than it did on the album. So for all of you who are scoffing at this single for its ridiculous, overhyped music video and its intensely pop feel, listen to the album version before you judge this song.

Verdict: Extremely good for the album version, mediocre at best for the single.